Are Indians too hard on India ?

... I think we are ...

Everytime I land in Chennai, I am inevitably one of the last people in the queue for Immigration (because I have this fixation for the emergency exit row in the back of the plane). And there is a long queue usually, because most flights to India are 747's. I am usually extremely impatient at this point and cursing India and everybody in the Bureau of Immigration. The longest its taken me is about 25 minutes.

And you know what, the shortest time immigration has taken for me in the US is 40 minutes ! And I have never ever complained about that.

I think we are too quick to criticize India and too slow to criticize the Western World.

Comments

Anonymous said…
Hi Ideamani,

I read your blog on and off and I think its really good.

Talking about immigration queues, I just wanted to share something.

I am a Malaysian Indian, studying in the US.
In Malaysia, we have this system, whereby the Malaysian passports have electronic-chips in them, pretty much like your credit card hv chips...
So, when a Malaysian holding his or her Malaysian passport enters or leaves the country, there is no stamping or anything of the sort.
We just place our passports on the scanner, and it electronically enters the passport holder's entry or exit info in the system.
There is not even an officer at the counter (for the Msian queue), so its really fast.

This is a very good passport system in my opinion.
Less pain for the freq. traveler esp.
Ideamani said…
But then couldnt people enter Malaysia with stolen passports considering that there is nobody to physically compare you to the photograph on the passport ?
Anonymous said…
Well, good point.
One reason the whole passport-e thing came up was for security.
If the passport got stolen, an expert could forge the passport and use it - change photo,name etc.
(Malaysia has a problem with Indonesian immigrants)

I think what happens with the e-passport is that, if it gets stolen, then u inform the police, this automatically goes in the system in customs...so the system will recognise that its a stolen passport/e-chip, and refuse entry/scanning...and I think there will be an alert..

Thats my understanding of it.
Ideamani said…
That is a loop-hole in the system then, because not everyone is going to know at once if their passport is stolen. for instance, as soon as I reach the US or India, I put my passport in a shelf and forget about it until I need to travel.
Anonymous said…
Hmm...well I would think that someone who wants to steal your passport...would have to go searching in your house in your shelf(how would they know where it is??)..and surely u must realize that your house was broken/messed up if that was the case.

There is loop hole in both systems, e-chip or not.
But if I stole an e-passport, I have a higher chance of getting caught for it, in a paper passport, if the picture is changed carefully enough, ie expert job, is much, much harder to get busted for years and years...

I guess its matter of opinion.
Also, while you cannot completely eliminate the loop hole with this system,
I guess you can reduce chances of stolen passports by random checks...

But really is there a 100% fool proof, loop-hole-less system for this?
Ideamani said…
Maybe if you can integrate the e-chip reader and a fingerprint scanner.
Anonymous said…
I just called my mum in Malaysia!
I was too curious u see...my mum literally asked me whether I was so dumb...??
She said that they scan both your finger AND your passport, she just came back into Malaysia couple of months back after a trip to India. So there...sorry...I forgot to mention that!
Ideamani said…
there you go ! That makes a lot of sense, and does'nt it feel great to get a technology lesson from your mother ;-)
thalassa_mikra said…
Idea, I read one of your old posts where you expressed a desire to go to Kovil restaurant in Connaught Place. Alas, that's not possible, because Kovil closed down about 5 years ago.
Ideamani said…
Oh no ! I was totally planning to go this time when I go to Delhi :-(

Guess I will have to make do with the good ol'Rodeo pub :-)
aruna said…
may be the reason is coz 40min in US airport is comfortable than 25minutes in chennai. When I went in 2002, they were renewing portions of chennai airport, and the place n smell looked like public toilet. I myself cant stand it for 1minute, and 45min waiting time in that place would be lonnnnnger n pathetic. More than me, I was worried about the foreigners, who were with me in that flight thinking abt what their first impression about india & how we greet them with a stinking enviro.
Anonymous said…
since you moved back to India you looks like you are just giving yourself reasons and consoling yourself as to why india is the best place to be in...
Ideamani said…
Oh, India is the best place to be, in my mind, without any doubt. There is no "consoling" involved.
Anonymous said…
hey! nice post.. i totally agree that we tend to be hard at times.. cribbing abt the govt/airlines/transport etc has become the favourite passtime of most Indians .. and we tend to over do it at times!
Ideamani said…
Hi Nandita Roche, thanks for your comment - This time you can't say that your comment went unacknowledged :-)
Anonymous said…
Btw Roche, i hope u ve not forgotten..u r Sri Lankan!
Anonymous said…
That was a very good post and I tend to agree with the point said. We do get impatient in India while we smile wide when it comes to waiting in US. And you also get the usual "Sorry" in US which makes the difference.

We try to get the Dress, technology and knowledge from US but the main thing most of the do not care is the Courtesy.

Moreover, when anyone cribs about the system, one should think about what he/she did something to correct it atleast for that present time and situation.

Good that you brought out this point.

Popular Posts